Who was the best composer of marches? Has anybody come close to John Philip Sousa?

3

3 Answers

HappyTo BeHereTo Profile

Sousa is synonymous with marches as we know them. 

Now I'm going off on a tangent, because I want to.

I've often wondered about the lost songs in history.  What got the ancient Greeks' toes tapping?  Did the Minoans have a "Billboard Chart?"  Did another culture have a Sousa or Mozart, and we'll never know?  I'd love to be able to listen to the first songs.

4 People thanked the writer.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
Wonderful perspective, Happy. What a shame they didn't have YouTube to give us access.

I was out walking this morning listening to some marches and it was surprising how they transformed my hobble into a stride.There have been lots of greater marches from lots of great composers, but nobody did it like Sousa.
HappyTo BeHereTo
HappyTo BeHereTo commented
I agree. We had fantastic marching band competitions in our area. One was exclusively Sousa. The man has an instrument named after him!
Cool Spot
Cool Spot commented
I haven't heard anything better. Maybe try looking at other official march songs from other countries and you will find something?
Walt O'Reagun Profile
Walt O'Reagun answered

Ironically ... Sousa didn't compose marches.  He composed waltzes - which worked better as marches.  So really, Sousa was a failure as a composer.

Virginia Lou Profile
Virginia Lou answered

Dear Didge,

I learned things from your question...no one to touch John Philip Sousa, but marches from composers I was surprised...

1. George M. Cohan (1878-1942), the "father of musical comedy," got a medal bestowed by FDR for (among other songs) his famous 1917 march OVER THERE that rallied the USA for both WWI and WWII. Cohan was famously portrayed by James Cagney in the 1942 movie "Yankee Doodle Dandy," which you could only call a propaganda movie...diluting the USA strong sentiment against entering both wars.

2. Scott Joplin (1854-1932), the African-American famous for ragtime, composed  THE ROSEBUD MARCH.

2 People thanked the writer.
View all 7 Comments
Virginia Lou
Virginia Lou commented
Dozy, I learned a great deal about WWII from that book.

And, oh I cannot recall his handle, you and I had discussions with someone who came on Ask only sporadically, he recommended the book IRRATIONAL MAN by William Barrett. For me that book was a watershed, I felt I understood more about how Western civilization got where it is....leading up to that horrendous twentieth century.
Didge Doo
Didge Doo commented
I must locate a copy. I'll see if my library has one.
Virginia Lou
Virginia Lou commented
This fellow was quite religious, you and he had some marvelous discussions...both of you very intelligent!

Answer Question

Anonymous