The Notebook .... I guess it appeals to the romantic heart of an old woman :)
I disliked. Both bad acting bad written. Go see schindlers list
Titanic. It made me cry whereas The Notebook just made me go "do people really do that?" pretty much throughout the whole movie. However I must say that what Noah did as an old man is rather touching. So yeah, movies that make me feel something or gets me thinking about it far after it's over are usually what I consider as good movies.
Neither. They were both awful, in my opinion.